| 1975 | Dave Meta |
| 1976 | Rick Broders, Myron Shewchuk |
| 1977 | Steve Cohen, Josh Wilbert |
| 1978 | Mark Gulas, Bob Schuerg |
| 1979 | Gary Szalkiewiecz, Garrett Wade |
| 1980 | Don Inwood, Don Rush |
| 1981 | ,Joe Grant, Bernie Simon, Dave Widger |
| 1982 | John Magro |
| 1983 | John Pace, Harry Sloate |
| 1984 | John Delap, Tony Valtos |
| 1985 | John Blanke, Paul Miceli |
| 1986 | Brad Barnhart, Eric Juhl, Paul Miceli |
| 1987 | Neal Johnson, Chris Younger |
| 1988 | Pete Cenek, Jason Gorevic |
| 1989 | Pete Cenek, Travis Donner, Jason Roy, Yuir Kostick |
| 1990 | Jim Chin, Brad Danneger, Brian Lunt. Scott Pachula, Cory Spence |
| 1991 | Dave Bodkin, Jamie Jackman, Jim Nuzzo |
| 1992 | Kurt Donner, Ryan Larsen, Henry Ospina |
| 1993 | Mark Genrizi, Joe Roy, Shawn Stephenson, Brad Weber |
| 1994 | Brian Bolger, Brad Dreher, Mark Genrizi, Braf Weber |
| 1995 | Adrian Calderon, Nate Lamkey, Chris Rhee, Justin Reed |
| 1996 | Graham Reinhardt, J. White |
| 1997 | Graham Reinhardt, Jeff Sansone, Adam Stadler |
| 1998 | Christian Lunt, Jeff Sansone, Adam Stadler |
| 1999 | Adrian Sak, Matt Stadler |
| 2000 | Colin Beazley, Paul Ronto, Matt Stadler |
| 2001 | Kevin Niwa, Kyle Patterson |
| 2002 | Ben Dyon, Ryan Miller |
| 2003 | Tommy Carlson, Nick Sutter, Phil Swarbrick |
| 2004 | Pat Hopkins, Scott Lorenz, Andy Miller |
| 2005 | Tom Hagenberg, Pat Hopkins, J.J. McKillen, Frido Rektorli |
| 2006 | J.J. McKillen, David Shaeffer |
| 2007 | Ryan Nolan, Jack Valentine |
| 2008 | Frank Ingraffia, Andrew Komnick, Tim Rudnicki |
| 2009 | Will Farrell, Tim Rudnicki |
| 2010 | Dan Barber, Craig Zahour |
| 2011 | Craig Zahour |
| 2012 | Ethan Claes, Dylan Nelson, Craig Zahour |
| 2013 | Connor Hennelly, Logan Morris |
| 2014 | Tyler Anderson, Austin Grzebieniak, Casey Slingo |
| 2015 | Luke Sellers |
| 2016 | Zach Carbonara, John Gadbois, Nash Pirie, Alex Ruffolo |
| 2017 | Enrico Ruffolo |
| 2018 | Cal Uhryniak, Colton Wever |
| 2019 | Daniel Hesselbein, Michael Horak, CJ Steib, Aidan Lew |
| 2020 | Daniel Hesselbein, Jeremiah Gascho |
| 2021 | Jeremiah Gascho, Mathew Klujian, Jack Peterson |
| 2022 | Mathew Klujian, Jack Peterson, Mattie Vitale |
| 2023 | Logan Cidulka, Andy Sfondilis, Mattie Vitale |
| 2024 | Jack Ball, Cooper Kim |
