| NSCAA ALL AMERICANS | IHSSCA ALL STATE PLAYERS |
|---|---|
| Dirk Pearson - 2003 | Niko Argyros --- 2020 |
| Nash Pirie - 2016 | Ethan Claes --- 2008 |
| Pat Deroche --- 2013 | |
| NSCAA ALL MIDWEST PLAYERS | Francesco Furio --- 2007 |
| Franceso Furio --- 2007 | Jeremiah Gascho --- 2021 |
| Pat Hopkins --- 2005 | Mark Gulas --- 1978 |
| Ata Ozbay --- 2008 | Pat Hopkins --- 2005 |
| Dirk Pearson --- 2003 | Mathew Klujian --- 2022 |
| Nash Pirie --- 2016 | Scott Lorenz --- 2004 |
| Paul Miceli --- 1985, 1986 | |
| Andy Miller --- 2004 | |
| NSCAA - National Soccer Coaches Association of America | Ryan Miller --- 2002 |
| IHSSCA - Illinois High School Soccer Coaches Association | Ata Ozbay --- 2008 |
| * POY = IHSSCA Illinois "Player of the Year" Award winner | Klaus Pallan --- 2016 |
| Dirk Pearson --- 2003 | |
| Giles Phillips --- 2014 | |
| Nash Pirie --- 2015, 2016 (POY) | |
| Jason Roy --- 1989 | |
| Carl Skanderup --- 1999 | |
| Matt Stadler --- 2000 | |
| Tom Unak --- 2007 |
